

Email
this lesson
Send
us feedback
Print
this lesson
|
 |
Aging 2: How Scientists Study Aging

Purpose
To help students learn how scientists study aging by reviewing experiments related to the affect of caloric reduction on aging.

Context
This lesson is the second of a two-part series on Science
and Aging and is more appropriate for advanced middle-school students
(8th graders). It builds on concepts presented in Aging
1: The Science of Aging.
This lesson helps students understand how scientists study aging, and specifically the study of the relationship between aging and caloric reduction. With advancements in health and medicine, along with a better understanding of the aging process, life expectancy for humans keeps increasing. It is probable that the life expectancy of today's middle-school students is going to be longer than the life expectancy of current adults.
There appears to be a maximum life span for each species, including humans.
Although some humans live more than a hundred years, most do not; the
average length of life, including individuals who die in childhood, ranges
from as low as 35 in some populations to as high as 75 in most industrialized
nations. The high averages are due mostly to low death rates for infants
and children but also to better sanitation, diet, and hygiene for most
people, and to improved medical care for the old. Life expectancy also
varies among different socioeconomic groups and by sex. The most common
causes of death differ for various age, ethnic, and economic groups. In
the United States, for example, fatal traffic accidents are most common
among young males, heart disease causes more deaths in men than women,
and infectious diseases and homicides cause more deaths among the poor
than among the rich. (Science for All Americans, p.
76.)
Students should begin to understand that there is both a physiological and emotional aspect to the aging process and that these two aspects are related. The aging process in humans is associated not only with changes in the hormonal system but also with disease and injury, diet, mutations arising and accumulating in the cells, wear on tissues such as weight bearing joints, psychological factors, and exposure to harmful substances. Sometimes diseases that appear late in life will affect brain function, including memory and personality. In addition, diminished physical capacity and loss of one's accustomed social role can result in anxiety or depression. On the other hand, many old people are able to get along quite well, living out independent and active lives, without prolonged periods of disability.
In this lesson, students will learn explore a website to learn how scientists are studying the relationship between aging and caloric restriction. This lesson should help students generally understand some of the factors involved in aging, but it is by no means comprehensive. Students can follow-up with more in-depth studies, including related concepts found in the following Science NetLinks lessons:

Planning Ahead
Materials:
In addition, to complete the Assessment section, it will be helpful for
students to review their notes from the The
Science of Aging student sheet.

Motivation
Continue discussing the concepts introduced in the previous lesson, Aging
1: The Science of Aging. Ask students the following questions to initiate
the discussion: - Why do you think people have always been so fascinated with trying to stay young?
- Do you think you can have any control over how you age?
- What factors do you think may have an effect on how long people live? Remember to consider both emotional, as well as physical factors. (Factors may include nutrition, economic conditions, environmental conditions, and genetics.)
- What types of studies do you think scientists would use to determine if there was a relationship between these factors and aging? (Cross-sectional and longitudinal studies of populations and studies on animals.)
- How might nutrition affect aging? How might scientists study the effects of nutrition on aging?

Development
Next, ask students to explore Defying
Death, on the Why Files website. Ask students to take notes related
to the questions in the How Scientists
Study Aging student sheet. Then, lead students through a discussion
about aging by asking the questions from the student sheet. (Please see
the How Scientists Study Aging
teacher sheet for the questions from the student sheet with suggested
responses.)

Assessment
Have students write an informal essay on the topic below. They should review their
notes from The Science of Aging
student sheet.
Compare the research techniques used in the studies of caloric restriction
with the cross-sectional and longitudinal studies discussed in the Secrets
of Aging. You should define each type of study and give an example
of each. Then answer this question: What can we learn by studying humans
directly and what can we learn from studies of other animals and how that
might apply to humans?
(The caloric restriction experiments used animals, such as rats, mice, fruit flies, and monkeys. The cross-sectional and longitudinal studies observed how humans age. By studying humans in cross-sectional and longitudinal studies, we can observe how they change, both physiologically and emotionally, from generation to generation or how one generation changes over a long period of time. By studying animals, we can learn how their different physiological systems are affected and try to draw conclusions about how this would affect humans. It is difficult to study emotional aspects of aging in animals.)

Extensions
To further explore topics related to science and aging, continue with the Science NetLinks
lesson entitled Nearsightedness.
The purpose of this lesson is to help students develop an understanding
of why scientific investigations may yield varying results. This lesson
gives students the opportunity to examine the nature of scientific research
in the context of research pertaining to myopia, or nearsightedness.
The following Internet resources can be used to further explore the topics related to science and aging:
- Science of Aging on PBS looks at the discovery of a set of "anti-aging" genes in animals that—when manipulated—have similar life-extending effects as calorie-restrictive diets.
- Live,
fast, die old, is an article summarizing
some of the research about the relationship between eating less and living longer.
- Life
Expectancy, a learning module from the World Bank, contains learning
activities that look at life expectancies around the world. It discusses
why life expectancy has risen in many countries but not all in others.
Created : 01/29/2002 |